
A single ink can only show so much of a photograph: the ink is either there or it is not, and on a mesh the lightest and the darkest tones drop out. A second ink, or a third, carries the tones the first one cannot. That is all a duotone or a tritone is: one grey picture, printed with several inks that each take care of a part of the tone range.
How a duotone works
In image software a duotone is stored as a single grey image plus one curve per ink. Each curve says how much of that ink goes where: at a mid-grey, perhaps 60% of the red and 0% of the black. For the press that becomes one film per ink, each a halftone of its own curve. Two inks give two films and two screens, three inks give three.
Why bother? A second ink extends the tonal range, and a light second ink can reach light tones that black alone cannot. The usual split is black, or the darkest ink, for the shadows, and a lighter ink for the midtones and the lights.
Six ways to build one
- Black plus one colour (duotone). The classic and the safest. The colour carries the lights and midtones, black only starts in the shadows.
- Black plus two colours (tritone). For example a warm ink in the lights, a cool ink in the shadows and a little black in the deepest part.
- Two colours, no black. Navy and orange, for instance. It only works when the darkest ink is truly dark (navy, aubergine, dark brown). A mid-blue leaves the shadows weak.
- Three colours, no black. Three transparent layers turn muddy quickly. Warm inks from light to dark (cream yellow, rust, aubergine) are the most forgiving.
- Tonal zones. Each ink gets its own part of the tone range and they hardly overlap: yellow in the lights, magenta in the middle, blue in the shadows. Graphic rather than photographic, and almost no risk of moiré between screens.
- Light inks on a dark surface. The curves turn round: the lighter the tone, the more ink. Opaque inks do not mix by overprint, and on a dark garment the light inks usually need a white underbase (see the underbase guide).
Setting the curves
Think in terms of which ink does which job, and keep the total coverage modest. These values are starting points for a first test, not rules:
| Ink | Lights (25% tone) | Midtones (50%) | Shadows (90%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Colour (red) with black | about 35% | about 75% | about 85% |
| Black with a colour | 0% | 0% | about 75% (starts around 45% tone) |
| Dark ink, no black (navy) | about 20% | about 50% | about 95% |
| Light ink, no black (orange) | about 55% | about 75% | about 30% |
A lighter second ink needs more coverage to hold the same tone, so the totals add up quickly: the sum of the inks in the deepest shadow can reach 150% or more. The CMYK mode of the tool caps total coverage at 240% for screen printing, and a duotone sits well below that; keep an eye on the shadows anyway, because thick stacked layers cure badly and fill in the dots.
- Start black late. If black starts early the whole picture turns grey and the colour is lost.
- Clip the picture first. If the darkest tone in your file is not really black, no ink will print a true black.
- Allow for dot gain per ink. A knit gains 15 to 35%, paper 3 to 10% (see one design, three surfaces).
Screen angles
Each ink needs its own angle, or the dots sit on top of each other and the colours shift when the registration moves. Common practice, from print forums and software help: keep the angles about 30° apart. For three inks 15°, 45° and 75° is often quoted, with the darkest ink at 45°, the middle one at 75° and the lightest at 15°. With two inks, different angles give a rosette instead of moiré and colour shifts when the registration drifts.
Screen printing adds a complication. The mesh itself makes moiré at 0°, 45° and 90° (see why 22.5° and never 45°), so the classic 45° is not ideal. Two ways out, both worth testing on your own frame:
- Classic: two inks at 75° and 45°, three inks at 15°, 75° and 45°. Best separation between the screens, 45° sits on the mesh weak spot.
- Mesh-safe: two inks at 67.5° and 22.5°, three inks at 11.25°, 33.75° and 56.25°. Every angle stays at least 11° from 0, 45 and 90, but the spacing between the screens drops to 22.5° or 45°.
Use the same line frequency for all inks and the same dot shape, and prefer an elliptical dot for smooth midtones. The tool’s CMYK mode uses fixed angles for the same reason (see CMYK without a RIP).
Print order and registration
- Light first, dark last. Print the lightest ink first and black or the darkest ink last, so the dark ink sits on top and sharpens the picture.
- Register tightly. A second halftone that drifts against the first softens the detail. Every extra ink is another pass and another chance to drift (see registration marks).
- Transparent or opaque? Transparent inks overprint into a third colour (transparent inks and overprint). Opaque inks cover what is under them, so nothing mixes.
- Print a test strip first: a tone wedge in each ink, and the wedge with all inks together, on your real material.
Making it with PrintFilmReady
At the moment PrintFilmReady separates artwork by colour and screens each ink at 22.5°, and the CMYK mode has its own fixed angles. A duotone needs a different angle and curve per ink, so for now make the separation in your image editor: apply one curve per ink, export each ink as a black-and-white film at the angle you chose, and mirror it. A duotone mode in the tool is being tested; there is nothing to announce yet.
Sources
- Photoshop tips: duotone vs multichannel images (CreativePro): one grey image and one curve per ink plate.
- Extending tonal range in Photoshop with duotones (CreativePro): why a second ink widens the tonal range, and black for shadows.
- Duo-, tri- and quadtones (Shutterbug): lighter second inks and tints.
- Screen angles: why 15, 45, 75 and 90 (PrintPlanet forum): the commonly quoted three-ink angles. A forum thread, so treat it as common practice.
- Do the screen angles of two trapping spot colours have to be different? (PrintPlanet forum).
- Degree settings in the colour halftone dialogue box (Adobe community): the 30° spacing rule of thumb.
Common questions
What is the difference between a duotone and a tritone?
A duotone uses two inks, a tritone three. Each ink gets its own tone curve, its own film and its own screen.
Do I need black for a duotone?
No. Black is the classic, because it gives the shadows their depth. Two or three colours work as well when the darkest ink is truly dark, for example navy or aubergine.
Which screen angles for two inks?
Common practice is about 30° apart, for example 75° and 45°. Because the mesh itself makes moiré at 45°, 67.5° and 22.5° is worth testing on your own frame.
Which ink do I print first?
The lightest first and the darkest, usually black, last, so the dark ink sits on top.
Can I do a duotone on a dark garment?
Yes, with light inks. The curves turn round (more ink where the picture is lighter), and the light inks usually need a white underbase.
Try your own picture
Separate it into inks and get one print-ready film per ink, in your browser. Free trial.
Built by a screen printer, for screen printers. What you tell us decides what gets built next. Write a review · Send an idea